Now, if only some of these were in theatres

Monday, 13 December 2004 — 5:28pm | Film

Film awards season is well under way by now with today’s announcement of the Golden Globe nominees. By no means is the Hollywood Foreign Press much of a legitimate critical body, but I follow them for the same reason everyone else does – because the Globes usually turn out to be a pretty good barometer for how things turn out around Oscar time, and also because they have a good track record of giving Pixar’s features the recognition they deserve.

The big story, as it stands right now, is Sideways with seven nominations as well as a sweep across the board in critical circles (including two of the big ones, New York and Los Angeles). Make no mistake – this year is shaping up to be between Sideways and Scorsese’s The Aviator, with the former being the frontrunner. The two aren’t going head-to-head in the Globes, but by the nomination count alone, it’s clear taking their respective categories.

Sideways is currently in limited release at the Uptown in Calgary and City Centre in Edmonton, but I have yet to catch it. It looks very much like the post-examination holiday is going to consist of a lot of catching up; Finding Neverland and Closer are already making a splash, while The Aviator, Million Dollar Baby and Hotel Rwanda are well on their way.

Part of why the various shortlists are so full of movies that have not seen wide release is that this is the second year where the awards season has been bumped up a month, with the Oscars now in February instead of March, and everybody else moving accordingly – but with the eligibility deadlines staying in place. It’s also the first year that this has mattered, since last year was an unstoppable The Return of the King sweep (with a tear shed for the under-awarded Finding Nemo). The only real factor left is the act of seeing some of these films perform, and get a vibe from critics and audiences en masse. It’s usually because of these considerations that independent, small-market releases have never made much of an impact at actually winning the Oscars for which they were nominated.

The first thing I observed in the recent gaggle of awards is that things do not bode well for The Phantom of the Opera. It picked up three Globe noms – one for the new Lloyd Webber number (hardly unexpected), one for Emmy Rossum’s performance as Christine (positively delightful news), and a nomination for Musical/Comedy where it is up against a very tough field including Sideways, The Incredibles, Ray and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. David Poland, who called Phantom a frontrunner upon seeing it last month, is still standing by it – somewhat. However, its absence on this year’s AFI Top 10 is worrisome. (Of course, they did shaft The Pianist back in 2002.)

As far as the AFI list goes, I’m glad to see both The Incredibles and Spider-Man 2 make the cut. Hopefully Phantom‘s on-and-off showing in awards circles so far is more a result of its not having penetrated the market, and it does turn out as well as we hope it will. In the end it’s not about awards, but what these awards tell us about what we can expect from Schumacher and company.

Back to the Globes: House of Flying Daggers and A Very Long Engagement are among the Foreign Language five. Jeunet’s latest collaboration with Audrey Tautou is a wildcard indeed – it could score big in the technical categories that the Globes ignore but the Oscars reward, and its ineligibility in the Foreign Language category could push it into contention.

Speaking of which, I am appalled that A Very Long Engagement has yet to play in Alberta – but at this time of the year, the arthouse screens can only handle so many major-league releases at a time.

Michael Giacchino’s work on The Incredibles did not recieve a nomination in the Score category. This is a crime, a baby-killing shame of a crime.

Other observations: Million Dollar Baby has yet to open in this province either, but I do wonder how it will stack up against Eastwood’s last release, Mystic River – a great film in many respects, albeit standard in others. As for The Aviator, let’s hope it doesn’t turn out to be another Gangs of New York – an awards darling early on that heralded the end of the Scorsese slump, only to undergo zero-for-ten Oscar shutout when everybody realized that it was only two-thirds of a good movie. And while I am not one to think awards should compensate actors and directors for previous robberies (see: Nicole Kidman and Renée Zellweger both receiving their Oscars a year late), it’s good to see both Leonardo DiCaprio and Paul Giamatti place so well. (This would be in reference to their breakouts in Catch Me If You Can and American Splendor, respectively.)

Kevin Kline is rightly recognized for De-Lovely, but what Ashley Judd is doing there is anyone’s guess. Uma Thurman is once again nominated for Kill Bill; judging by that and Eternal Sunshine‘s presence, at least the HFP hasn’t totally forgotten everything prior to the month of November.

In summary – Phantom, please don’t flop.

The Return of the King, Extended Edition, sees release tomorrow. Regrettably, unlike the past two Extended Edition releases, I am not able to be the first on the scene this time; a review in excruciating detail will have to wait at least another week.

Annotations (0)


Polly want a cipher

Sunday, 12 December 2004 — 1:10pm | Literature, Michael Chabon

If you are still engaged in the holiday ritual known as Christmas shopping, here’s the perfect gift for literary types: Michael Chabon’s freshly-released novella, The Final Solution. It’s a quick read, spanning a mere 131 pages, but boy, is it ever nice to get Chabon’s words in a package that can be digested in a sitting or two.

If The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay was at its core a tribute to Jack Kirby, then in The Final Solution, Chabon pays his respects to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Set in 1944 wartime England, it follows an eighty-nine-year-old former sleuth that has retired into beekeeping as his powers of deduction are enlisted for one last case involving a mute Jewish refugee boy from Nazi Germany and his parrot, Bruno. The protagonist is only ever identified metonymically as “the old man,” but he is clearly implied to be Sherlock Holmes in his twilight years. In this respect the premise is similar to Unforgiven, where Clint Eastwood’s William Munny is an obvious throwback to the Man With No Name he played in Sergio Leone’s spaghetti westerns, only here in Chabon’s book, the decay explored is intellectual rather than moral.

The mystery itself, on the plot-summary surface, is fairly standard, and befits the complexity of a short story. The twists lie not in the deductive process of revelation, but in the solution at which we finally arrive. Where Chabon excels, as he always does, is in his total mastery of the language.

Today’s literary environment exhibits a widening division between serious art literature that you read for the majesty of the words, and non-serious escapist literature that you read for fun regardless of how it’s written. Michael Chabon bridges the chasm like nobody else (as if that purpose, the celebration of escapism, were not already the explicit theme of Kavalier & Clay). For those who care about good writing, you can bathe in his words and yet derive a sense of dream fulfilment from his romantic fantasy backdrops. For those who dabble in comic books, Baker Street investigations or (in the case of Summerland) a union of Norse mythology, Native American folklore and sandlot baseball, you have the rare privilege of lauding the storyteller not just for the story, but also for the telling.

In The Final Solution, this is very much the case. It’s a simple, perhaps even unremarkable Sherlock Holmes story to begin with, but it’s the telling that makes it all worthwhile. If we recognize that Chabon has already mounted the summit of the fun, artsy novel, here he conquers the fun, artsy novella. He does some remarkable things with his prose; an exquisitely detailed scene of the old man working the hives, his first sight of a war-torn London, a climactic chapter written entirely from the perspective of a parrot – a dazzling feat of animal personification, even by the high standards of someone who has read William Horwood’s Duncton Wood.

But that’s already saying too much. This holiday season, give the gift of a good book.

Annotations (2)


First impressions of Gorgonzola cheese

Wednesday, 8 December 2004 — 11:30pm | Literature

Rejoice, ye citizens, for here be a literary post.

A series is an interesting thing to commit to (terminating preposition fully intended). Theoretically, the easiest to get into are the ones that lack an overall narrative arc, where the brand-name power resides strictly in a central character or characters. If you take Agatha Christie’s Poirot novels, for example, you don’t necessarily have to start with The Mysterious Affair at Styles to have a grasp on what the Belgian sleuth is up to in Murder on the Orient Express (though admittedly, a familiarity with Styles is a necessity prior to tackling Curtain: Poirot’s Last Case). In fact, someone who begins with Orient Express will notice nothing familiar about it being told in the third person rather than narrated by Poirot’s analogous Watson, Captain Hastings.

The trouble with these, of course, is knowing what to read first. I keep hearing people tell me how well Pratchett and I would go together, but they all scurry away as soon as you ask them where to start. It’s always tempting to start with the earliest-published work, but it’s like trying to evaluate Star Trek: The Next Generation based on the first season – you risk an unfair appraisal because often, the author has yet to find his footing. Occasionally you will have a genre-defining maven like Raymond Chandler who had his rhythm in order right away (that being Philip Marlowe’s debut in The Big Sleep), but that’s hardly a common occurrence. Sometimes the first book in the series is a really good read, but lies prior to the establishment of any conventions that only come out through repetition; this is the likeliest explanation of why Ian Fleming’s Casino Royale has yet to be adapted to film, the Peter Sellers-starring spoof aside. And sometimes, an author’s early work is just plain bad; of this, there are too many examples to list.

The type of series you hear a lot more about nowadays is the one where each successive volume may have a self-contained unity of its own, but claims as its primary purpose to develop an overriding story arc where each entry keeps you guessing about the next. As before, sometimes it takes a few books for an author to really start delivering the goods, but the constant here is that in order to make heads or tails of what is going on, it is in your best interests to start with the first one. The overriding continuity drives both the story and the sales.

This creates an interesting trap. Let’s say an author builds moderate success with his first few books and establishes a dedicated fan base that expands via word-of-mouth. He opens up a number of dangling plot threads that yearn to be resolved, and pull you onwards. The series reaches a saturation point where every new release is going to sell. Once an author develops this hit-churning momentum, the editors offer less scrutiny. This can lead to one of two things: either the author refines her craft and sharpens her wit like a knife, adding dimensions to the story that are unexpected, yet insightful and consistent (see Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix); or conversely, spirals out of control and goes patently nuts for several hundred content-free pages at a time, but compels you to read on anyway because those plot threads remain unresolved (see any of Robert Jordan’s later works – the exact point whereat he falls apart depends on how much you let him tax your patience).

I just finished A Game of Thrones, George R.R. Martin‘s first volume in his saga A Song of Ice and Fire (currently consisting of three volumes, with a target of six). It was recommended to me by someone who reads a lot of fantasy, but would benefit (as I believe everyone would) from being a cross-genre reader who dabbles in everything. To his credit, this was one recommendation that was on the ball. I came out of this first book with a very positive impression, and I think I know why. Martin captures everything that worked for Robert Jordan – the backroom squabbling of prissy nobles in overvalued estates, pre-Westphalian kingdom-to-kingdom “international relations” if you will – and dispenses with most of the annoyances.

What Martin has that Jordan doesn’t includes, but is not limited to, the following: controlled shifts in perspective that present new information in a logical manner; conscious discernment between characters who matter and characters who don’t; no silly names with random apostrophes; seven hundred pages of action and development, not ten at the beginning and ten at the end; minimal internal monologue that does not beat the reader upside the head; chapter endings that keep you interested without trailing off in ellipses; the conspicuous and welcome absence of Mary Sue; an overall narrative flow that contains the polyphony of stories being told; a demonstrated ability to write prose.

(Admittedly, Jordan does have Martin beat when it comes to video-game boss battles. I say that flippantly, but it is honestly and tellingly one of The Wheel of Time‘s recurring highlights.)

On that point about the silly names with random apostrophes: the consistency with which Martin’s nomenclature falls into a schema that reminds one of Middle English (yet demarcates cultural distinctions in language, as with the Dothraki) is quite remarkable. Mind you, this is something that we should normally be able to take as given, but nomenclature in modern fantasy is so wildly out of control nowadays that it’s a relief to see an author do it in a way that doesn’t outright suck.

His prose is fairly standard fare, and while it leaves a lot of room for study, style is not in any way the locus of his literary depth. Martin’s storytelling manner won’t wet a critical reader’s pants, but to its credit, it fails to annoy. This is clearly the kind of book where the narrative is at the service of the plot. As far as thick paperback tomes go, A Game of Thrones is highly readable, and part of it is because the plot is so well constructed. It’s a risky, gutsy story that treads in a murky sea of moral ambiguity. The best kind of plot for a Romantic tale of this overarching scope is where it feels very much like the author tossed all the characters in a cauldron and let them boil amongst themselves; the reader should never see him stir. If you start caring about certain characters that meet untimely ends (and in this book, do they ever), it comes off as your own damned fault.

I hear that in A Clash of Kings and A Storm of Swords, Martin stays on track. I’ll evaluate that claim soon enough, but classify it as good news.

The other series opener I just read was the first in Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events (The Bad Beginning). Apparently, the upcoming film will also incorporate events from The Reptile Room and The Wide Window, which isn’t entirely surprising, given the brevity of the first book. That is to say, it’s really short. On the upside, it’s also the soul of wit.

Snicket (or would that be his “representative,” Daniel Handler?) writes at a level that is readable by an audience younger than Rowling’s, but his control of the language (even amidst self-imposed limitations of length and vocabulary) is masterful. But that’s only one aspect of what I managed to glean from 162 pages in large print.

Maybe this comes from writing a recent paper on the assessment of performative speech acts in “Signature, Event, Context” – but I can’t help but feel that Lemony Snicket is Jacques Derrida for kids. I kid you not. In the key sequences of The Bad Beginning we see a fictitious enactment of precisely what Derrida says in celebration of contexts for performative acts (in this case, the classic example of the “I do” of a wedding ceremony) that J.L. Austin dismisses as parasitic. This isn’t even a matter of analogy – the example comes directly from Austin’s claim that a theatrical performative isn’t valid or legally binding, and Derrida’s response that we would never recognize it as felicitous in the first place were it not a repeatable formula.

Then we get to Violet’s coup de grace at the climax of the novella, which I will not spoil here, but hearkens back to what Derrida says in the same essay about the validity of a written signature acting in the absence of a speaker. This isn’t just kid lit, guys – this is a tour de force of twentieth-century thought condensed into the most deceptively elementary package imaginable.

In conclusion, I really should have started reading Lemony Snicket a long time ago, because I could have written a much, much better term paper. I do plan to get through the rest of the series soon in conjunction with the considerably more voluminous second and third parts of A Song of Ice and Fire, among other books – The Bad Beginning is short, sweet and readable in one easy sitting, and its ten sequels don’t look much longer.

Annotations (0)


Café Canadien Sampler Platter

Saturday, 4 December 2004 — 5:16pm | Film

If the rigorous movie analyses and Scrabble game logs at this establishment are the scrumptious sushi selections on the menu, posts like the one you are about to read would be the assorted tempura.

There isn’t much on my Christmas wishlist this year, but on it is the 1950-1952 volume of The Complete Peanuts, which is already on shelves. Schulz’s early work that sprung off his Lil’ Folks panels, when the characters were even younger than how we have come to know them, has in the past seen very little in the way of publication. Now is as opportune a time as any to start collecting the entire run of Peanuts in tandem with this project.

Geoff Pullum picks on Dan Brown again, and as always, echoes my own feelings in a far more eloquent manner. “The great thing about filming Dan Brown’s novels,” he says, “will be that it will get rid of his execrable expository prose.”

On some of their vintage DVD releases, Warner Brothers includes a feature entitled Warner Night at the Movies, which attempts to re-create the way movies used to be presented; the main feature is preceded by a trailer, newsreel, animated short, and live short, all selected from the same year as the film’s release. It’s a commendable mode of presentation, and film buffs should appreciate such classics as The Adventures of Robin Hood and Yankee Doodle Dandy being given such a respectful treatment.

I mention this because local readers may find some amusement in this tidbit: on the DVD of The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, the included newsreel features one segment on a fire-eater delighting the kids of one Edmonton, Alberta. The footage is brief and contains nothing that identifies the city in a way one could distinguish today, but it’s there.

The next set of films to get the Warner Night at the Movies treatment is the Warner Gangsters Collection to be released in January. It’s hard to get a hold of these pre-Maltese Falcon pictures where Bogart is in his early phase as a supporting hoodlum while Cagney is in his first-billed prime, so these restorations are much appreciated.

Speaking of box sets, put this on my Christmas list as well: the Criterion Collection Akira Kurosawa: Four Samurai Classics (The Seven Samurai, The Hidden Fortress, Yojimbo and Sanjuro). So many DVDs, so little time.

Today I saw Happnin’, the U of A Jazz Choir, perform their Fall Concert. To put it succinctly, I would see them again, and so should you; there are more performances to come next year, including their Spring Concert (2 April) and an appearance at the Rocky Mountain Music Festival in Banff (14-17 April).

David Yates is as good as confirmed to be sitting in the director’s chair for Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. Personally, I think Jeunet shouldn’t have turned it down, but he would have been better for one of the early films anyhow. And it’s a shame nobody caught on to just how perfect Terry Gilliam is for this particular chapter in the Potter saga, but with both The Brothers Grimm and Tideland on his plate, it hardly fits into his schedule anyhow.

On a final note, my television is tuned to a channel emulating a fireplace and playing easy-listening music. Weird.

Annotations (0)


Bye bye, Miss American Pi

Wednesday, 1 December 2004 — 4:13pm | Classical, Music

This is less a marriage of music and mathematics than a summer fling of sorts, but I’ll let the pi10k experiment speak for itself:

This experiment attempts to convert the first 10,000 digits of pi into a musical sequence.

Select ten notes, and your corresponding selection translates into an integer. The first note you select will equal “1”, the second “2”, and so on. As your computer cycles through the digits of pi, the corresponding notes will “play.”

Those of you who can make heads or tails of a basic keyboard layout should try it out.

A few comments: First of all, I think the experiment would be on the whole far more interesting if you introduced a number of other factors. The first is that this would be a whole lot more interesting if prior to iterating over the digits of pi, you first converted everybody’s favourite transcendental circumference-diameter ratio into base 12 (0 through 9, A and B), and proceeded to assign notes from there covering the entire twelve-note octave. It would make for some variety, to say the least. Perhaps it would produce the same brand of atonality as what one would expect from, say, Schoenberg’s twelve-tone technique.

The next thing I did was plug in a C blues scale to see what kind of a jazz-me-up solo you can do with pi. This reminded me of two things: first, sitting on the same chord and the same key for more than a few bars at a time is boring. Maybe if it was automatically transposed up to F and G blues scales in accordance with the prototypical twelve-bar progression, it would be a whole lot more interesting. Second, pi (as it is implemented in that particular experiment) could do with some rhythm. Maybe if each of the digits were assigned a relative rhythmic value, the band would be swingin’.

This got me thinking about the iterability of musical sequences, and whether or not there is a systematic way to generate traditional consonance-dissonance tensions by formula without having to resort to an atonal result like the one we have here. Let’s go back to fundamentals here, and examine the circle of fifths. It occurred to me that if you cycle through these, as you do in the traditional vi-ii-V-I cadence back to the tonic, you begin to see that this particular foundation of music theory is a cyclic algebraic group of order 12. (Consider the V-I to be the “operation” in question, thus making the IV-I the “inverse.”)

Now that you have the roots of the chord progression in place, what remains is to map it to a harmonic pattern – your basic major, minor and diminished triads, or the more interesting texture you get when you add a major or minor seventh up top. If you look at the bridge to Gershwin’s “I Got Rhythm” – in B-flat rhythm changes, it goes D7-G7-C7-F7 – the iteration is done entirely over the dominant seventh. This is by itself not very interesting until you add some substitutions, say an alternation with changes every two beats instead of four: Am7-D7-Dm7-G7-Gm7-C7-Cm7-F7. Maybe throw in some tritone substitutions to boot, inverting the third and the seventh of the dominant chords, which is a common substitution trick that translates into some fancy bass lines.

But what does such a series have to do with something as random as pi? How can you generate tonality out of that randomness?

Well, the answer to that is, take advantage of the fact that pi isn’t all that random, and use a numerical approximation algorithm. Euler’s isn’t of much use here, unless you figure out a way to assign arctangents to chords, but if you take something simpler like Newton’s recursive expansion, you’re in business.

In fact, you can try something like this with any infinite series – geometric, Taylor, MacLaurin, what have you. All it takes is to find an analogous operation that moves from chord to chord or note to note (or better yet, manipulates the push-and-pull of time in a systematic rubato) and assign it to the operations the series uses to generate each successive term.

I’ll end with a fun fact that hardly anybody knows (until now): back in high school, I won $25 in a St. Patrick’s Day limerick contest, wherein I did a few stanzas on pi. I had to take a bit of a liberty in rhyming “Euler” with “ruler” (it’s actually pronounced “Oiler,” as in that local hockey franchise), but nobody noticed.

Annotations (0)


« Back to the Future (newer posts) | A Link to the Past (older posts) »